10/19/2005
Oldest Specks
In my column of April 13, I mentioned briefly the work of John Valley, Professor of Geology at the University of Wisconsin- Madison. Valley was one of a group of workers who found that a speck of zircon was the oldest “rock” on Earth. I didn’t know then the details of their work. Now an article by Valley in the October Scientific American reveals the story of the amazing measurements he and his colleagues have made on zircons smaller than the size of the period at the end of this sentence.
After forming 4.5 billion years ago, Earth was an awful place, fiery hot and molten, bombarded by objects from space. Until recently, prevailing wisdom was that over 500 million years passed before Earth’s surface cooled enough for a crust to form and for water to form oceans. The earliest rocks known to have formed in an aqueous environment were 3.8 billion years old. Fortunately, there are regions where very old rocks are exposed, ripe for the picking by geologists. One such place is the Jack Hills region of Western Australia, where our tiny zircons were discovered back in the 1980s. Zircon is a mineral composed of the elements zirconium, silicon and oxygen.
In the 1980s, Simon Wilde was a member of a group at Curtin University of Technology in Australia that combined forces with William Compston and his group at the Australian National University in Canberra to study the zircons. Compston’s group had invented an instrument they called SHRIMP (Sensitive High-Resolution Ion Microprobe). SHRIMP was a special ion microprobe, an instrument that shoots a beam of ions at a sample. The ion beam digs a tiny pit in the sample, kicking off the atoms from the sample to be fed into another instrument called a mass spectrometer. The mass spectrometer measures the masses and amounts of the atoms ejected from the sample. If you know the mass, you know the element.
The Australians were particularly interested in using SHRIMP to measure traces of uranium and lead in the zircons. Why? The amounts of uranium and lead indicate the age of the zircon. When the tiny zircon crystals formed billions of years ago they typically contained a trace of uranium. Uranium is radioactive and as it emits particles it is transformed into other elements that are also radioactive. The net result is that the uranium ends up as lead, a stable element. A key number in calculating the age of a zircon is the half-life of uranium. All the uranium doesn’t turn into lead at once. Otherwise, there wouldn’t be any uranium on Earth today. If you start with a certain amount of uranium, it will take some time before half of that uranium has transformed itself to some other element by emitting a particle. That time is the half-life. By a curious coincidence, over 99 percent of uranium is an isotope with a half-life of 4.46 billion years, essentially identical to the age of Earth, 4.5 billion years.
What does this mean? Let’s pretend we find a 4.46 billion-year- old zircon. Half of the original trace uranium in the crystal will have turned to lead. SHRIMP tells us we have equal amounts of uranium and lead. For zircons not as old, less than half of the original uranium will have converted to lead. Valley says that a 4 billion-year-old zircon can be dated to within plus or minus 40 million years, an uncertainty of only 1 percent. You’d be hard pressed to estimate most people’s ages that well!
Well, the Australians in the 1980s found that their oldest zircons dated as far back as 4.3 billion years, only 200 million years after Earth was formed. This was exciting but the nature of the parent rocks was unknown. Zircon is a very stable mineral and the parent rocks weathered away, leaving the tiny zircon crystals at the mercy of wind and water, which carried many far from their source. Some of the zircons are crystals with flat faces and sharp angles (probably ones that stayed near where they formed) while others have rounded edges, worn down over the years on their journeys.
John Valley came into the zircon story when he approached Wilde to cooperate with one of Valley’s graduate students in his doctoral research. Wilde agreed and measured over 50 zircon crystals using an updated SHRIMP. To get these “less-than-a- period” size zircons they had to crush and sift through hundreds of pounds of rock. In 1999, he found a zircon in which the lead was almost equal to the amount of uranium. That zircon was 4.4 billion years old, only 100 million years after Earth was formed.
While Valley and his graduate student, William Peck, must have been overjoyed to find such ancient zircons, they weren’t finished. They took the 5 oldest zircons to the University of Edinburgh in Scotland, where John Craven and Colin Graham had another ion microprobe that specialized in oxygen isotopes. Ordinary oxygen is O16 but there’s also a rare isotope O18, with two more neutrons in its nucleus. The ratio of O18 to O16 in a crystal depends on the temperature when the crystal forms. The researchers were “stunned” to find that the O18 to O16 ratios in the zircons implied that the zircons were formed under low temperature conditions where water was present.
Hesitant to publish their findings indicating that Earth cooled down 400 million years sooner than was thought previously, they held off for a year. Meanwhile, others confirmed their results on Jack Hills zircons and papers appeared in 2001. But Valley and Peck still weren’t finished. They also found in the oldest zircons pieces of other minerals, notably quartz. Quartz and the presence of certain other trace elements suggest that the zircons were associated with the formation of a continental crust much earlier than expected.
How did these researchers get all these data from such tiny samples? They mounted the crystals, some nearly invisible to the naked eye, in epoxy and polished them (very carefully!) to expose a fresh surface. I’ve potted crystals in epoxy and polished them but they were big crystals. I can’t imagine polishing a mere speck, not just once but several times. After each ion probe measurement of uranium and lead, they polished away the pit to expose a new surface for the oxygen work, and another for the trace element work. That tiny 4.4 billion-year-old zircon has traveled all the way from Australia to Wisconsin to Scotland and, if all went according to plan, it is or will be back in Australia to be housed on display in a museum there.
About 35 years ago at Bell Labs, we were experimenting with O18 in gallium phosphide. A colleague and I went to Elmsford, New York to the Cameca Instruments Company, where they had an early version of an ion microprobe. We spent a couple of long, frustrating days there. As I recall, the problem was that we couldn’t tell the difference between O18 and H2O, normal water (with O16) and O18 having very nearly the same mass. The instrument was not sensitive enough to tell the difference. I can empathize with Valley, who spent 11 sleep-deprived days of “round-the-clock” analysis on the ion microprobe in Scotland. Thankfully, he had a vastly better outcome than we did.
Today, labs all over the world are working on zircons and the number over 4.1 billion years old is in the hundreds! Back in Wisconsin, Valley now heads up a lab that has acquired a new Cameca “cutting edge” ion microprobe, which will be used to look at zircons and other materials ranging from stardust to cancer cells. I can’t wait to see what comes next.
Allen F. Bortrum
|